Salary or dividends
There is no permanent right answer. Here is how we work out the mix with each client, every year.
By Mohammad Khoshghalb, CPA, CGALast reviewed
Every owner-manager asks me this question, usually in the first meeting: should I pay myself a salary or dividends? My answer is always the same. It depends on your numbers this year, and it will probably change. Anyone who tells you one is always better than the other is not looking at your situation.
Salary is a deduction for your corporation and employment income for you. It builds RRSP room, because RRSP room is based on earned income and dividends don’t count. It also means Canada Pension Plan contributions, and as an owner you pay both halves, the employer’s and the employee’s. If you have young children, salary matters for another reason: the child care deduction is limited by earned income, so a spouse paid only in dividends may not be able to claim it. Banks also tend to prefer a T4 when you apply for a mortgage.
Dividends are simpler. There are no payroll remittances and no CPP. They are paid from income the corporation has already paid tax on, and you receive a dividend tax credit to recognize that. But dividends build no RRSP room and no CPP pension, so if you take only dividends, all of your retirement savings has to be built somewhere else, usually inside the corporation.
The tax system is designed so that the total tax on salary and on dividends comes out close. That is why the decision is rarely about this year’s tax alone. What tips it is everything around it: how much cash you need personally, whether you want RRSP room, your child care claims, and what is going on inside the corporation. If your company earns investment income, paying salary reduces its business income, which helps protect the small business rate. If the company has refundable tax or a capital dividend balance, paying the right kind of dividend can release it.
Here is how we handle it at MKG. Because we prepare both your corporate return and your personal return, we see both sides. Before your year-end, we look at five things with you: your personal cash needs, your RRSP and CPP position, your family’s deductions, the corporation’s investment income, and the balances available to pay out at low or no tax. Then we set the mix for the year. Most of our clients end up with some of each, and the split moves as their lives and their businesses change.
If nobody has reviewed how you pay yourself in the last couple of years, that is the first thing I would look at. Call us at 416-836-4731.
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Tax rules change, and how they apply depends on your facts. Speak to us before you act on it.
